Source licensing: what actually covers our reuse of planning-register data
Referenced from our DPIA and About page. This is a copyright/database-rights question, separate from our UK GDPR lawful basis for personal data (covered in our legitimate interests assessment and DPIA). This is an open legal question we are putting to our solicitor, not a settled or minor item - see "What is not yet resolved" below before relying on anything in this document. Draft, awaiting solicitor sign-off.
Three separate rights, not one blanket licence
- The statutory public-register right. Local planning authorities are required by the Town and Country Planning Act regime to keep a public register of applications open to inspection. This is a right to inspect, not a copyright/reuse licence, and it does not by itself authorise redistribution of the content in a commercial product.
- Database/copyright permission for the register content itself, at each individual council. This varies by authority and has not been individually verified for any of them. Some councils publish their general website content under OGL terms; some planning-portal platforms (Idox, Northgate, and others) carry their own terms of use, distinct from OGL, covering how their own hosted data may be used. We have not checked any of these individually, and nothing below changes that - our aggregator's own terms (point 3) do not establish what a given council's platform separately requires, because our aggregator cannot grant rights in content it does not itself own.
- Our aggregator's own terms, as our direct source (we do not scrape councils ourselves). Our source is PlanIt (planit.org.uk), run by one person, Andrew Speakman. It has no dedicated terms-of-service page; its FAQ and acknowledgements page are the only policy text that exists, both re-checked and re-quoted here on 17 Nov 2026 (the FAQ carries no other date on the page).
What PlanIt actually says, quoted directly - not summarised into a conclusion
| Topic | Exact wording | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Open Government Licence | "Great Britain postcode data may be used under the terms of the Open Government Licence"; "Great Britain and Northern Ireland boundary data may be used under the Open Government Licence." No OGL statement anywhere covers planning application records themselves - the FAQ does not mention OGL at all. | Acknowledgements page, "Postcodes" and "Boundaries" sections, read 17 Nov 2026 |
| Commercial use - the permissive line | "You can use the data from this site for anything you want. No attribution is necessary." | FAQ, "Are there commercial terms for using the PlanIt API?", read 17 Nov 2026 |
| Commercial use - the warning, same answer, immediately after the line above | "A donation is always appreciated, but sadly this is not a commercial enterprise and there are no commercial terms." / "However, as noted above, it would not be wise to base any commercial services on the system in the long run." | Same FAQ entry, read 17 Nov 2026 |
| Continuity warning, stated separately from the commercial-use warning above | "The site is run by one person on a 'best efforts' basis which means that there are no guaranteed service standards... it would not be wise to base any commercial services on the API." | FAQ, "What is the future of PlanIt?", read 17 Nov 2026 |
| Why the operator avoids explicit terms | "I want to avoid any potential legal and contractual issues which might arise if my actions could be interpreted as implying ownership of the data." | FAQ, "Is the full PlanIt dataset available?", read 17 Nov 2026 |
| Documents (plans/drawings) | "Documents with plans, drawings and material submitted to local authorities are protected by the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (section 47...)... Further copies must not be made without the prior permission of the copyright owner (the applicant / agent / architect etc)." | Acknowledgements page, "Documents" section, read 17 Nov 2026 |
| Funding and commercial status - corrected from an earlier draft | "The site is run as a retirement hobby. It is not a commercial or for-profit enterprise." But also: "it is funded by a small income from a closed list of clients who pay for access to the underlying scraping software" - not donations alone, as an earlier version of this page said. That client list is separately described as "limited in size and currently full." | FAQ, "How is PlanIt supported?" and "Are there commercial terms for using the PlanIt API?", read 17 Nov 2026 |
Permissions register
| Source/material | Relevant terms | Attribution required? | Restrictions | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning application records (address, description, type, decision, dates) via PlanIt's API | No stated licence of any kind for this material specifically (see table above - OGL is stated only for postcode/boundary data, not records) | Not required by PlanIt ("no attribution is necessary"), but that line is about PlanIt's own data, not about whatever a given council's own platform may separately require | None stated by PlanIt for redistribution; PlanIt's own commercial-use warning is a caution, not a stated prohibition (see "What is not yet resolved") | Unresolved per-council rights; PlanIt's own position assumed, not a council-by-council verification |
| Documents/plans/drawings linked from a council's file | Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, s.47 | N/A - we do not reproduce these | Consultation-purposes use only; no further copying without the copyright owner's permission | Verified, and already our practice - we link to the council's own file, we do not republish or copy the document itself |
| GB/NI postcode data | Open Government Licence (postcodes), ONSPD licence (NI) | Per OGL terms | Per OGL terms | Verified |
| GB/NI boundary data (nearby-councils feature) | Open Government Licence; OpenStreetMap boundary data separately under ODbL | Per OGL/ODbL terms | Per OGL/ODbL terms | Verified |
| Individual council/platform terms (Idox, Northgate, council websites) for the records they publish | Unknown - varies by authority, not checked for any of the authorities we cover | Unknown | Unknown | Not checked - a real gap, not assumed resolved by PlanIt's own position |
Two separate risks, not one
Permission to reuse the data (do we have a right to redistribute planning-register content in a commercial product) is a legal question, assessed above and still open. Service continuity and availability (will PlanIt keep operating, keep its API stable, keep answering requests) is a business-continuity question, about reliability, not rights. PlanIt's FAQ raises both in the same breath ("there are no guaranteed service standards... it would not be wise to base any commercial services on the API") but they do not have the same answer: a source can be unreliable and still have granted adequate permission, or can be perfectly reliable and have granted none. We treat them separately below rather than letting one stand in for the other.
What is not yet resolved - stated plainly, not rounded up to a conclusion
- We do not conclude that an absence of stated commercial terms means there are no enforceable restrictions. PlanIt not publishing formal terms is not the same as PlanIt (or the underlying councils) having no rights to enforce; UK database right and copyright can exist and be enforceable without a published licence saying so.
- We do not conclude that accepting this risk establishes that we have reuse rights. The owner's decision to keep operating while this is assessed (below) is a commercial risk choice, not a legal finding that redistribution is permitted.
- We do not conclude that building our own in-house data collection (scraping councils directly, bypassing PlanIt) would resolve this. It would remove our dependency on PlanIt specifically and the continuity risk that comes with a single, one-person, "best efforts" source - but it would not resolve the underlying question of what each individual council's own site or platform terms permit, which is a separate, still-unchecked question either way (see the permissions register above).
- We do not conclude that PlanIt's own terms make the underlying councils' rights irrelevant. PlanIt cannot grant us a right it does not itself hold; its FAQ is evidence of what PlanIt thinks it can offer, not a determination of what the underlying data's rights-holders have actually licensed.
- We do not describe any of this as cleared. The per-council/per-platform rights question (point 2 above) remains genuinely open, going to our solicitor alongside the LIA/DPIA.
Owner's risk decision - stated for what it is
9 Nov 2026, restated 17 Nov 2026 with the above made explicit: the product continues to run on PlanIt's API while the permissions question above is assessed. This is the owner's acceptance of commercial and continuity risk while the legal question is open, not a finding that the risk is low or that reuse rights are confirmed. Building an in-house replacement that collects planning data directly from councils is logged as an urgent post-launch priority (see DECISIONS.md, 9 Nov 2026) - framed, per the point above, as addressing continuity and the PlanIt-specific relationship, not as a substitute for checking individual councils' own terms.
What the public-facing wording says
We describe the data as coming from public planning registers via an aggregator, note that copyright/reuse terms vary by source, and keep the OGL reference only for things we have actually verified it covers (postcode and boundary data). We do not claim a blanket licence for planning records anywhere on the site.